 |
| BHAC/FGIC Collaboration (MSRB) |
After a post I did a few days ago on Detroit's
2011-12 budget, I found out that Berkshire Hathaway's
AAA rated subsidiary, Berkshire Hathaway Assurance Corporation, insured $767 million Detroit revenue bonds on a second-to-pay basis. These bonds were re-marketed and converted into fixed rates in 2008. Berkshire insured
$385 million Detroit water revenue bonds (official statement at msrb.org) and
$382 million Detroit sewage disposal revenue bonds, but only if bond insurer FGIC failed to pay. Principal and interest payments are backed "solely" by net revenues of pledged assets (water and sewage funds), not by taxes like general obligation bonds.
At that time the large muni bond insurers, Ambac, MBIA and FGIC, were being downgraded as losses mounted on toxic credits they insured (MBS). As a result, Buffett wanted to leverage his AAA rating and grab share in the muni insurance market. Issuers wanted Berkshire's guarantee because it lowered interest payments. Berkshire eventually "pulled out of municipal bond insurance" when he thought he wasn't being compensated for the risk (
GuruFocus). Read Buffett's 2008 investment letter below for more details. It is interesting that Financial Guaranty Insurance Co.'s parent company, FGIC Corp., filed for bankruptcy in August 2010 and its insurance company had its muni bond insurance reinsured by a division of MBIA in early 2009. Counterparties squared.
"The majority of FGIC Co.-insured bonds were reinsured in January 2009 by National Public Finance Guarantee Corp., the investment-grade, muni-only insurer owned by MBIA Inc." (Bond Buyer)
From
Bloomberg on May 1, 2008 on the Detroit bond deal:
"May 1 (Bloomberg) -- Detroit sold about $383 million of bonds carrying insurance from Berkshire Hathaway Assurance Corp., marking the first foray by Warren Buffett's four-month- old guarantor into the primary market for U.S. municipal debt."
"Detroit sold Berkshire-backed bonds at yields ranging from 2 percent on debt due in July to 4.75 percent on bonds set to mature in 2027. The largest single series of bonds -- $136 million of debt paying a 5.75 percent rate and due in 2031 -- were priced to yield 4.67 percent, 13 basis points less than Municipal Market Advisors' index of top-rated debt at similar maturities. A basis point is 0.01 percentage point."
More information from
The Bond Buyer (4/30/2008):
"As the finance team crafted the transaction, they met with several monoline bond insurers with the hope of leaving the FGIC policy in place and bringing in a secondary insurer for additional protection. Officials considered Financial Security Assurance - which insures a remaining piece of the water and sewer bonds - but the insurer backed off because of its heavy coverage of much of the city's outstanding debt.
Only Berkshire Hathaway was interested in acting as a secondary insurer with FGIC, according to a source. "They didn't have the same idea about FGIC being in place on the bonds as the other insurers had," he said. "The Berkshire insurance really gilds the lily [on the bonds]." It will mark the first time that BHAC will act as insurer on a primary market transaction, officials said."
Credit ratings in the news:
Fitch Drops $4.6 Billion of Detroit Water and Sewer Bonds (
BondBuyer, April 1, 2011)
Detroit Water and Sewer Revenue Bonds Are Downgraded by Moody’s (
BusinessWeek, December 20, 2010)
Since Berkshire Hathaway was directly involved in analyzing municipal credits before the market and economy collapsed in 2008, Warren Buffett is probably a decent source for analyzing municipal credit risk. In Buffett's 2008 letter, he warned about the potential risks involved in insuring muni credits. Read the full portion about tax-exempt bond insurance after the jump.
"Insuring tax-exempts, therefore, has the look today of a dangerous business – one with similarities, in fact, to the insuring of natural catastrophes. In both cases, a string of loss-free years can be followed by a devastating experience that more than wipes out all earlier profits. We will try, therefore, to proceed carefully in this business, eschewing many classes of bonds that other monolines regularly embrace."