 |
| Source: Reuters Blogs |
First, some background on what happened between GreenLight Capital and Punch Taverns.
David Einhorn's hedge fund GreenLight Capital was recently fined £7.2 million by the U.K Financial Services Authority for trading off inside information that was disclosed during a (non-wall crossed) conference call with former Punch Taverns (PUB.LSE) CEO, its CFO, and Punch's Merrill Lynch broker Andrew Osborne in 2009, who was also
fined (read the full
transcript at fsa.gov.uk (pdf), and read
Greenlight Capital's response to the fine).
At the time, Punch wanted to raise capital to repay £220 million of convertible bonds, and have "10% headroom" on covenant ratios attached to securitization vehicles. For more info on how pub securitization works, read this
paper by Fitch Ratings (2003). Osborne mentioned in the call that Punch would need to issue £350 million, which would dilute Einhorn's 13.3% position in the company significantly. So, Einhorn dumped his shares after the call, avoided a £5.8 million loss when the stock tanked, and was fined for insider dealing. So that happened. But the whole point of this post is to show you what Einhorn said during the conference call.
Einhorn, one of the top value fund managers out there, who
publicly releases extensive research at times (recently GreenLight and
T2 Partners went publicly short St. Joe Co. and
defeated the Fairholme Fund), gave his views on how to manage Punch Taverns' capital structure during the call, and explained how highly levered equities "trading at less than 50% of the face value of debt" are essentially "options on the debt-side of the capital structure", which was interesting. The blog
Distressed Debt Investing had an interesting post on this as well. He mentioned that Einhorn made a successful investment in a "Levered Stub Basket" at the end of 2008, which ended up making 227%. I actually found
GreenLight's year-end 2009 letter that mentioned this (courtesy of DealBreaker):